Like Manny Paquiao and Floyd Mayweather, Orlando City and The Tampa Bay Rowdies are taking far too long to take advantage of an obvious business opportunity, developing a natural geographic rivalry and giving the hardcore fan basis of both teams what they want.

This is an obvious opportunity for two teams that are still floundering in the purgatory which are the minor American soccer leagues and aspiring to greater goals. The two teams are moving in very different directions however and are currently about as close to crossing paths with respect to talent and support as we likely ever will be.
The Tampa Bay Rowdies are a team named after the historic NASL franchise that was founded in 1975. The Rowdies achieved a great amount of success, including winning the NASL title in it’s first year. The team was well supported in the community, reaching a peak average attendance of over 28,000 fans in 1980. The Rowdies set the roots for the Tampa Bay Mutiny, one of the original ten MLS franchises.


With star players like the great Columbian legend, Carlos Valderrama and MLS record breaker Roy Lassiter, The Mutiny achieved a decent amount of success on the pitch making the playoffs four of six years, finishing first in the regular season in the inagural year and winning the first supporters shield.

The Mutiny however were only met with mediocre support at the gate, always finishing well below average in attendance in every year of it’s existence. In it’s final year, the Mutiny had it’s second ever worst year at the gate, averaging just under 10,500 fans per game and finishing in last in the Eastern Conference of the MLS. While many Tampa soccer fans will tell you that the team folded in 2001 beause of mismanagement and the inability to find a local buyer, fan support for the club certainly was not exactly a favorable variable in the team going bust and becoming insolvent.
In 2010, the second coming of the ‘Tampa Bay Rowdies’ was founded in the new NASL, nine years after the death of the Mutiny. The new club has received modest support, averaging just under 3,500 fans per game in it’s first two seasons.

In talks of MLS expansion, Tampa is not even in the conversation. The most ardent Rowdies supporter would likely admit to as much. That said, Tampa has a rich soccer history and technically plays in a higher division then Orlando City.
The professional soccer history in Orlando can be traced back to 1985 and the foundation of the Orlando Lions, the sport made it’s real enterence to the Central Florida community with the 1994 World Cup.



Founded in 1985, the Orlando Lions existed for 11 years in various start up minor American soccer leagues from the ASL, APSL, USISL, USISLPL and USL indoor. While hardcore soccer fans like my father introduced me to the Lions at a very young age, watching them play at area High Schools, outside of the passionate followers of the sport, it is safe to say most of the community was not familiar with the team.
Building up to the 1994 World Cup, Orlando hosted numerous friendlies and it is safe to say that the city caught soccer fever in anticipation of hosting the world’s biggest sporting event.

The World Cup was a wild success in Orlando. Every game was at or near capacity with over 60,000 fans (61,219 capacity at the time). The city however was not able to capitalize on this triumph and bring MLS soccer to Orlando. After the World Cup, a relative dark age period of soccer begun in Orlando while MLS was growing throughout the country. For diehards like myself, my only fix for live professional soccer was the occasional exhibition match in the city or to make the shlep to Tampa and see the Mutiny. The only sense of community I had among my fellow soccer fans was at my local pub in St. Andrews Tavern for the occasional EPL fixture.

Even though we did have the Kraze playing in the PDL and a couple professional indoor teams who came and went, those looking for a steady fix of professional soccer in Central Florida were left thirsting for more.
I have always known the potential of the Orlando market is thru the roof. Orlando has a rich history of active youth soccer leagues, a rich international community and a thirst for an additional professional sport franchise to support outside of the Orlando Magic.

In what may likely be seen as the single most important moment in the history of professional soccer in Central Florida, Phil Rawlins bought the USL professional soccer rights in Orlando and moved the Austin Aztecs to the city beautiful. Rawlins quickly has proven to be a savvy franchise owner quickly building the most successful team and organization in the USL in only it’s first year in the market. By supplying the appetent soccer fan base in Orlando with a professional team of their own, becoming an active part of the community and showing a genuine respect for the fans, Phil Rawlins and Orlando City soccer club are now among the favorites to land the next MLS franchise.

Detractors will quickly point out that while the first year support for OCSC was impressive, the team could still prove to be nothing more then a one year wonder. The history of Central Florida soccer has been relatively brief and outside of the 1994 World Cup, truly insignificant if we are intellectually honest. It is yet to be seen if this community has the support to maintain longevity.
So here we stand. Tampa, led by it’s boisterous supporter group, ‘Ralph’s Mob,’ are looking to reestablish themselves as a soccer hotbed and MLS expansion candidate after decades of mismanagement, missed opportunities and a nostalgic desire to return to soccer glory. While they have a rich soccer history full of high’s and lows, a recognizable name brand in the Tampa community and playing in the D-II NASL, Tampa fans still see the Rowdies as a better team then the ‘nouveau riche’ Orlando City Lions.
In 2011, Orlando City had the most successful American soccer franchise outside of MLS in it’s inaugural year. While the 2012 season is yet to be played, as an active member of the Orlando soccer community, I can tell you first hand that every indication is that not only will City be able to sustain it’s eyebrow raising inaugural year support; it will grow significantly. I will genuinely be shocked if Orlando City averages less then 7,000 fans per game in the USL regular season in 2012. Led by two very active and growing supporter groups, City is no longer knocking on the doors of MLS but breaking down all barriers into the top flight with a battle-axe.


I openly admit that I biased. I think the Tampa Bay Rowdies are nothing more then a relic. Whereas Ralph’s Mob might genuinely be a passionate group of fans that love the sport, they live in a fantasy world yearning for days gone by and thinking of what could have been with the Mutiny. They had their chance and they blew it. For all the excuses of having no interested buyer prior to folding, the Mutiny could have survived if the community would have supported them. By averaging a meager 10k-12k year in and year out, Tampa proved they were not interested in the MLS. I look at the Rowdies with a mix of pity and a touch of disdain. Why disdain? Well in typical Tampa arrogance towards all things from Orlando, many supporters of the Rowdies are still scoff their noses at the Lions and see us as an inferior D-III product.

In the mean time, Orlando City supporters would like nothing more then proverbially pop the Rowdies in the mouth for their blind arrogance. We don’t think we are better then the Rowdies; we know it. It’s about time that they learn this as well. Orlando City runs laps around the Rowdies in every possible dimension with the exception of team history and legacy. The countless organic ‘we hate Tampa’ chants that were sung by the ILF practically every game were real and speak to a genuine dislike of our West Coast neighbors.
So we come full circle. The ‘X’ and ‘Y’ intersects of the two cities professional soccer paths may never be this close again. While I believe Orlando is on the fast track to the top flight of American soccer and the Rowdies will continue to wallow in the minors, at this precise moment we are as close to even as we may ever be on the pitch and with regards to fan support.
Make this game happen now. While Orlando City still covets respect. While the Rowdies would love nothing more then to put OCSC in what they perceive to be their rightful place as an inferior team. Years from now the disparity in talent between these two squads might be so great that this potential rivalry will likely lose its luster.
Regardless of what happens on the pitch between these two squads, the Lions and the Rowdies are heading in much different directions. The stakes and bragging rights may never be higher. It would be wise for the management of both teams to make this game happen…